Answering My Inbox. Manhattan Grit, Manila Grace. Tish Vallés, CEO. All issues

Answering my inbox · Issue No. 11

Everyone Already Knows

Manhattan Grit, Manila Grace.

The Question

A director asked

“Our company has bought from a vendor owned by one of our directors for years. It's genuinely the best price we've found, and everyone on the board knows about it. Do we actually have a problem, or is disclosure enough?”

Disclosure is good, and you have it. But disclosure isn't a governed arrangement, so on its own it isn't enough.

The Manhattan Read

Two scuba divers above a sunken wreck encrusted with coral, one holding an underwater camera rig
It has been down there for years. Someone still has to go and document it.

A properly governed related-party arrangement needs four things, and “everyone knows” gives you only the first.

  1. Disclosure. The board is aware. You have this.
  2. Recusal. The interested director steps out, formally, for both the discussion and the vote. Check whether that actually happens or is simply assumed.
  3. Independent assessment. Someone outside the arrangement verifies the terms against the market. “It's the best price we've found” is a claim to be checked, not a conclusion to be accepted.
  4. A record. Minutes that show the recusal happened and the terms were verified, not just that the topic came up.

This isn't a consultant's wish list. The Revised Corporation Code already sets conditions for contracts between a corporation and its own directors, and those conditions are about process: whether the director's presence or vote was needed to approve the deal, and whether the terms were fair and reasonable. Good intentions don't appear on that list. A record of how the decision was made does.

Here's why the gap matters more than it feels like it should today. When this arrangement is tested, by an incoming investor, a disputing shareholder, a regulator, or a falling-out between directors years from now, the question won't be “did the board know?” It will be “show me the process that approved this on arm's-length terms.” Informal awareness, however genuine and however long-standing, has no answer to that question.

It's the same trap as the board that only meets when something's on fire, wearing a different outfit: comfort standing in for structure, until the day structure is what gets asked for.

The Manila Read

A warehouse worker marking a carton by hand while a colleague looks on
Write it down while the relationship is easy, not when someone asks you to prove it.

I understand the discomfort of formalizing scrutiny over an arrangement with someone you trust: a fellow director, a friend, and in many family-governed companies, a relative. Insisting on an independent check can feel like accusing them of something, especially when the arrangement really is fine.

But that instinct points the wrong way. Formalizing the arrangement doesn't cast suspicion on the director. It's what clears them, permanently and on the record. Without it, the arrangement stays fine only for as long as nobody outside the room asks a hard question. And when that question finally comes, the person most exposed isn't the company. It's the director, whose name is on the vendor and whose good faith now has to be reconstructed from memory.

That's the relationship this protects. Years from now, someone who wasn't in the room will look back at an arrangement everyone once considered obviously fine and ask why nothing shows it was ever verified. At that point, “everyone knew” reads less like trust and more like a habit nobody examined.

Build the process while the relationship is easy, and you spare the director a defense they should never have needed to make.

The Move

Put a related-party policy in writing this quarter, and apply it to the arrangements you already consider settled.

  1. A standing disclosure requirement, refreshed every year.
  2. A recusal protocol for the interested director, covering both discussion and vote.
  3. An independent benchmark of pricing and terms, at least once a year.
  4. Minutes that record the recusal and the independent approval, not just the agenda item.

Start with the vendor you already have. If the terms really are the best available, the policy costs you nothing and proves it. If they aren't, you want to find out before someone else does.

Where This Shows Up

This is the governance architecture eCSI builds and keeps running for client boards at the operating-company level: the related-party policy, the recusal and approval protocol, and the board record that shows each step happened, working alongside legal counsel where the framework needs it.

And when the harder part is raising the subject with a director everyone trusts, that's a conversation I design and facilitate myself.


This is where the inbox opens. Have a boardroom, conflict-of-interest, or fiduciary question keeping you up at night? Send us your situation and it might be next week's burning question.